The leadership crisis at the Fountain of Life Church has moved from the pulpit to the courtroom, with Pastor Jimmy Odukoya challenging his removal as senior pastor in a fresh lawsuit against his sister and seven other church figures.
Odukoya filed the suit at the Federal High Court in Lagos on Friday, November 20, alongside the Incorporated Trustees of the Fountain of Life Church.
In an earlier report, the underfire clergy maintained he had received counsel from senior clerics in Nigeria. However, it seems the succession case is not going anytime soon.
The case, marked FHC/LAG/CS/1568/2026, names Tolu Odukoya, Biodun Balogun, Biodun Awosika, Rotimi Okpaise, Tobi Enuha, Gbenga Onabanjo, Fred Ohiani and Akin Osinbajo as defendants.
He is asking the court to declare the meetings and resolutions that led to his removal invalid and determine whether the church’s Board of Trustees followed its constitution.
At the centre of the dispute are meetings held on January 22, February 28 and November 16, 2026, by a group describing itself as concerned trustees of the church.
Odukoya argues that the decisions taken at those meetings violated the church’s constitution, particularly the provisions governing the appointment and removal of its senior pastor.
He is also asking the court to determine whether the Board of Trustees can remove a senior pastor through a resolution without following the procedure stipulated in Article VII, Section 39, alongside Article VIII, Sections 45(c) and (g), of the church’s constitution.
The pastor maintains that his appointment was legitimate. According to his court filings, the Board of Trustees unanimously appointed him senior pastor and chairman of the board at an emergency meeting on September 14, 2023. He was subsequently installed that month.
The latest action follows an earlier legal move by the opposing trustees. On November 18, the Lagos State High Court issued an interim order restraining Odukoya from presenting himself as the church’s senior pastor and spiritual head.
The court also restrained him from interfering with the church’s governance, administration and activities. The order was granted ex parte, meaning the court made it at an initial stage without first hearing his response. The matter was adjourned until December 1.
The disagreement is rooted in a succession arrangement allegedly made by the church’s late founder, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya.
The opposing trustees released a video reportedly recorded in December 2021, in which the late founder named Pastor Kunle Areogun as his preferred successor if he died or became incapacitated.
In the recording, Jimmy was assigned administrative responsibilities and leadership of the church’s youth ministry under the proposed arrangement.
The trustees said the recording was not presented when Jimmy was appointed in September 2023 and only came to their attention later. They argue that the succession instructions should guide the church’s leadership structure.
But Jimmy disputes the authority of the trustees to remove him. He insists that his appointment was valid and that the decisions against him did not comply with the church’s governing constitution.
The dispute has also exposed disagreements over the composition and authority of the Board of Trustees, the church’s administrative structure and the handling of its leadership transition.
Following the announcement of his removal, the opposing trustees named Pastor Rotimi Okpaise as interim spiritual and administrative leader.
The competing positions now leave the church facing two separate court proceedings over who has the authority to lead its affairs.
Odukoya and those backing his leadership stand to retain their position if the court upholds his argument that the removal process violated the constitution. The opposing trustees, meanwhile, are seeking to enforce the succession arrangement they say the late founder established. Church members are caught between the competing leadership claims, with the outcome likely to shape the institution’s future governance.
The Federal High Court has yet to determine the issues raised in the new suit.
Bottom Line: The Fountain of Life crisis is no longer simply a disagreement over who succeeds a founder. It is now a legal test of whether a church’s leadership can be changed through internal resolutions or must follow the rules written into its constitution.



